Helping Students to Ask Better Questions in English Class

One of the most useful things students can learn in English isn’t how to answer questions. It’s how to ask better ones.

At the start of the year, most class discussions follow a fairly predictable pattern. Students focus on what happened in the text or what a particular word means. Those questions help with basic understanding, but they rarely take the discussion very far. The more interesting conversations start when students begin asking questions that show they are genuinely trying to figure something out.

Why questioning matters in English

English is full of ideas that don’t always have one clear answer. Students are often expected to interpret meaning, analyse how a text works, and explain why different readers might see things differently. Questioning plays a big role in helping them do that.

When students begin asking better questions, they start to look at texts more closely. Instead of just accepting what they read or hear, they start noticing how writers shape ideas and influence readers.

Good questioning helps students:

• look beyond the obvious meaning of a text

• notice how writers shape the reader’s response

• challenge ideas instead of accepting them straight away

• consider different viewpoints and interpretations

These shifts might seem small, but they quickly improve the quality of classroom discussion.

A small change that helps straight away

One simple strategy is to slow things down before the discussion even begins. After reading a passage or watching a clip, ask students to write down one question they have about it.

The key is that the question should come from their own thinking rather than from a worksheet.

At first, students might ask questions like:

→ Why would the character even do that?

→ I don’t get why the writer put that bit there.

→ Are we meant to like this person or not?

→ Did anyone else think that ending was weird?

→ How does this link to what happened earlier?

They are not perfect analytical questions, but they show students are thinking about the text. That’s usually enough to spark a much more interesting discussion than the ones we carefully plan.

Getting students to build on each other’s ideas

Another routine that works well is encouraging students to respond to ideas with a question rather than an answer. When one student makes a comment, the next person tries to extend the thinking.

For example, a student might say they think a character seems confident.

Instead of moving straight on, another student might ask what details made them think that.

If a student suggests a news clip feels dramatic, someone else might ask what choices made it feel that way.

This approach keeps the discussion focused on one idea instead of jumping from topic to topic. Over time, students become more comfortable questioning each other’s thinking and explaining their reasoning.

Questioning works with any kind of text

Once students get used to asking questions, they start noticing things they might have missed before. This works just as well with films, speeches, articles, and novels.

Students might start asking questions like:

• Why does the writer keep returning to that detail?

• Are we supposed to trust this narrator?

• Why is this moment placed here in the story?

• Who are we meant to feel sympathy for in this scene?

Questions like these move students beyond simply understanding what happens in a text and towards analysing how meaning is created.

Helping students develop the habit

Like most skills in English, questioning improves with practice. It also helps when students realise that questions can serve different purposes. Some questions clarify meaning, some push ideas further, and others challenge whether something really makes sense.

Once students see questioning as a thinking tool rather than something the teacher controls, they begin using it more naturally when reading, listening, and discussing texts.

Over time, the classroom dynamic changes. Students begin asking questions, interpreting ideas, and reconsidering their thinking as discussions develop.

Discussions feel less like a series of teacher prompts and more like genuine exploration of ideas. Students stop waiting for the teacher to provide the questions and begin asking the ones that matter themselves.

If you’d like a structured way to teach questioning skills in your classroom, we’ve created a Critical Thinking: Questioning Skills teacher guide with student handouts, routines, and practical classroom activities.

---

STAY IN THE KNOW!

✿ Subscribe to our YouTube channel

✿ Follow us on TikTok

✿ Follow us on Instagram

✿ Follow our Facebook page

✿ Follow us on TPT.

📬Add some joy to your inbox📬

🥝 NZ Teachers, click here to subscribe for teaching tips and our latest products (or log in to the website then you can access our Freebies library too)!

🌎 Teachers from other parts of the world, click here to subscribe for teaching tips and our latest plus get instant access to our bank of freebies!